M A G A Z I N E

The Crash on Netflix, The True Story Behind the Ohio Murder Case

Firefighters and police officers investigating a heavily damaged car beside a brick building.
Rocks Off Mag

At around 5:30 in the morning, a Toyota Camry slammed into a brick building in Strongsville, Ohio, at nearly 100 mph. Two young men died. The 17-year-old girl driving the car survived with serious injuries.

Police initially investigated what appeared to be a terrible road accident. A few months later, they arrested the driver, Mackenzie Shirilla, and accused her of deliberately killing both passengers.

Netflix documentary The Crash, released on May 15, 2026, revisits the case through police evidence, courtroom recordings, family interviews, and a conversation with Shirilla herself. The documentary also gives viewers a chance to hear why her family continues to challenge the murder convictions.

What Happened in Strongsville, Ohio?

On July 31, 2022, Mackenzie Shirilla was driving her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, 20, and their friend Davion Flanagan, 19, home after a graduation gathering.

Shortly after turning onto Progress Drive, Shirilla accelerated toward an industrial building. Her car went through a business sign before crashing into the brick wall of the Plidco building.

The impact was devastating. Dominic and Davion died at the scene, and Mackenzie was taken to a hospital.

The case also highlights how devastating high-speed collisions can be, a danger reflected in research on the cars involved in the most accidents in America, which examines fatal crash rates across different vehicle models.

According to the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office, a passerby discovered the wreckage around 45 minutes after the crash.

Investigators had to explain why a car traveling on an otherwise ordinary road had accelerated to such an extreme speed and struck a building without any sign of braking.

Why Did Police Believe the Crash Was Intentional?

Mackenzie Shirilla wearing a gray hoodie in a personal video shown in Netflix's The Crash.
Unlike a jury trial, a bench trial places the responsibility for determining guilt entirely in the hands of a judge.

The investigation changed direction when detectives obtained surveillance footage and examined the vehicle’s event data recorder, commonly called a black box.

The footage showed Shirilla making a controlled turn before accelerating along the road. The car then traveled at close to 100 mph before hitting the building.

Data recovered from the Toyota showed that the accelerator was fully pressed during the five seconds recorded before impact. The brakes weren’t applied.

Investigators also examined the vehicle for mechanical problems. They found no defects that explained the collision.

Mechanical failures are only one possible explanation for a collision. A closer look at the most common causes of car accidents in the US shows how different factors can contribute to serious crashes.

Another important part of the case involved the relationship between Shirilla and Dominic Russo.

Prosecutors presented evidence that Dominic had tried to end their relationship. Witnesses also described an earlier incident in which Shirilla allegedly threatened to crash a vehicle with Dominic inside.

The prosecution argued that the earlier threat, the driving recorded on surveillance footage, and the vehicle data pointed to an intentional act rather than a driving mistake.

What Did Mackenzie Shirilla Say Happened?

Shirilla has maintained that she didn’t deliberately crash the car.

Her defense argued that she might have experienced a medical emergency behind the wheel. She had previously been diagnosed with postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, known as POTS, a condition that can cause dizziness and fainting.

According to her defense, Shirilla might have lost consciousness and been unable to control the vehicle.

Prosecutors disagreed. They pointed to the controlled turn before the acceleration and argued that the physical evidence didn’t support a sudden medical episode.

The case went to trial in August 2023. Shirilla waived her right to a jury trial, leaving Judge Nancy Russo to decide the verdict.

The judge found her guilty of murder, felonious assault, aggravated vehicular homicide, and additional drug-related offenses. The court concluded that she had intentionally caused the crash.

Shirilla received two concurrent life sentences with the possibility of parole after 15 years. Concurrent means the sentences run at the same time rather than one after the other.

Where Is She Now?

 

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

A post shared by People Magazine (@people)

Shirilla remains imprisoned at the Ohio Reformatory for Women in Marysville, Ohio.

Her first parole hearing is scheduled for September 2037. She will be 33 years old at that time.

The hearing doesn’t mean she’ll automatically leave prison. Under Ohio’s Parole system, the board reviews eligible prisoners and decides if release under supervision is appropriate. Her sentence permits that review after 15 years, but she could remain incarcerated for much longer.

Her legal challenges have also continued. The Ohio Supreme Court denied a reconsideration request in September 2026. According to October reporting on the case, new attorneys filed another appeal notice arguing that mistakes by her previous legal team affected her ability to challenge the convictions.

The latest filing doesn’t overturn the guilty verdict or change her prison sentence.

What Does the Netflix Documentary Reveal?

Director Gareth Johnson had access to police footage, private recordings, courtroom material, and interviews with people close to everyone involved.

The documentary gives considerable attention to the relationship between Mackenzie and Dominic. Friends and family members describe different sides of their time together, including arguments and signs of trouble that emerged before the crash.

Dominic’s family discusses the recordings and messages that became important during the investigation. Davion’s relatives explain how the loss affected them and why they believe the guilty verdict was justified.

Mackenzie’s parents offer another perspective. They believe their daughter wasn’t responsible for intentionally killing the two young men and continue to support efforts to overturn her convictions.

One of the documentary’s most significant moments is an interview with Mackenzie inside prison.

She hadn’t testified at her trial and hadn’t previously given a public account of what happened. Speaking to the Netflix filmmakers, she said she couldn’t remember the moments immediately before the crash.

She also repeated her belief that a medical emergency was responsible.

Her lawyer was present during the interview, which lasted about an hour. Netflix later explained the circumstances in its report about Shirilla’s first public interview.

The conversation is an important addition to the documentary, although it doesn’t change the evidence considered at trial or the existing verdict.

Why Are People Still Debating the Case?

The argument surrounding The Crash largely comes down to intent.

Nobody disputes that Shirilla was driving or that Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan died in the collision. The disagreement concerns what caused her to accelerate into the building.

Her supporters question the medical evidence and argue that investigators didn’t adequately consider the possibility that she lost consciousness.

Prosecutors maintain that the vehicle data, surveillance footage, and evidence about the relationship establish that the crash was deliberate.

The courts have already considered many of those arguments. In September 2024, an Ohio appeals court upheld the convictions, finding sufficient evidence to support the trial verdict.

Then, in March 2026, another Ohio appeals court decision upheld the dismissal of Shirilla’s petition for postconviction relief. The petition had been submitted one day after the applicable 365-day deadline.

The ruling concerned the filing deadline, not a new determination of what happened inside the car.

The documentary’s release brought additional attention to the case. In May 2026, Strongsville police publicly released around 32,000 text messages and recorded jail calls connected to the investigation.

The Netflix filmmakers said they had already examined that material during production. The messages have since encouraged further online discussions about the relationship and the prosecution’s interpretation of events.

Final Thoughts

If you enjoy documentaries that examine real investigations and court cases, The Crash has plenty to hold your attention. It runs for about 95 minutes and includes footage and interviews that weren’t part of much of the original television coverage.

For viewers interested in more nonfiction storytelling, our selection of the best music documentaries explores other real-life stories through archival footage and personal interviews.

The filmmakers don’t simply reconstruct the collision. They spend considerable time with the people who knew Dominic, Davion, and Mackenzie before that morning in July 2022.

Some footage is upsetting, including recordings made by police after the collision. The film also discusses a troubled teenage relationship, drug use, and the consequences of the murder convictions.

Tags:
Share this story
M A G A Z I N E

Rocks Off is a digital magazine covering music, culture, lifestyle and everything in between. Informative, entertaining, and always curious, we tell the stories behind the headlines, from timeless classics to what's new today.